The Hole in Global D&O

June 26, 2008

by John Cummings

What used to be known as "American-style" class action litigation is rapidly becoming the global norm. That's particularly true in Europe, where a broad swath of countries including Denmark, Germany, the Netherlands, and the United Kingdom have recently enacted laws making it easier for shareholders to bring collective suits against corporations. Class action rules are also gaining ground in Asia. South Korea and Taiwan now provide legal mechanisms for group litigation of securities fraud claims. China's New Company Law, which came into effect in 2006, grants shareholders the ability to enforce a range of new rights through derivative and direct lawsuits.

To mitigate these risks, the vast majority of U.S.-based multinationals rely on global coverage extended from the D&O policies they purchase for U.S. exposures. In a new survey from professional services firm Towers Perrin, only 3 percent of participants with international operations said that their organization has purchased separate D&O coverage for individual countries.

That worries Michael Turk, senior consultant with Towers Perrin, because many countries require that D&O policies be filed with locally licensed carriers. Policies that don't meet that criterion -- "non-admitted" policies -- are not permitted to pay claims, regardless of the policy language. And that could leave local directors and officers exposed.

"A number of companies that didn't buy a local policy before are now doing so," says Turk, "but that raises other questions -- What does the policy cover? How broad is it relative to the U.S. program, and so on -- so it can get pretty complex as to how you actually implement the coverage you need in that country. The survey results showed that organizations are not, for the most part, addressing these issues just yet."

D&O is not the only line of coverage that's affected by local jurisdictions' admittance rules. General liability, for example, faces some of the same issues, notes Dave Bradford, executive vice president of Advisen Ltd. in New York City. "For years, some insurance policies have provided worldwide coverage, and then the question arises: How does that apply to countries where the legislation requires local policies?"

On the D&O side, non-U.S. exposures have generally not been considered as significant as those that arise within the United States. But that's starting to change. "It's an issue that has grown and become more visible as more countries have changed their laws to allow class action activities that would never have been allowed before outside of the United States," says Turk.

U.S.-based multinationals should carefully examine the risks, understand the local requirements and then determine the best approach for providing the coverage, says Turk. Some U.S.-based insurers may be able to issue local policies in the key jurisdictions that an organization needs to cover. But the key is to be aware of the risks. "Over the next few years, companies are going to want to be addressing this exposure much more carefully than they have in the past," he says.

See the full Towers Perrin report "Directors and Officers Liability: 2007 Survey of Insurance Purchasing and Claim Trends" here (requires free registration).

Average: 9.3 (3 votes)

Wholesale Wallet China

Wholesale Wallet

China Wholesale

Writing Instrument Baby Products Suppliers 0.736328348
Heating Products

Bottle Carriers

Wholesale Album Wholesale Poncho 0.738611252
Recorder Pen

Cleaner Products

Promotional Gifts Wholesale Coaster 0.267552117
Wholesale Cup

Silicone Watch

Fishing Supplies Wholesale USB Flash Drive 0.427690442
Wholesale Calendar

Wholesale Apron

Wholesale Racks Wholesale Jewelry 0.287038954
Wholesale Album

Lunch Box

Wholesale Waterproof Case Bottle Opener 0.843528253
Medicine Instrument

Eye Mask

Wholesale Jewelry Wholesale Playing Card 0.23665178
World Cup Products

Beauty Equipment

Water Bottle Voice Recorder 0.588196469
Wholesale Thermometer

Tin CD Case

Wholesale Bedding Wholesale lable 0.195585803
Wholesale Tellurion

Wholesale Scissors

Mouse Pad Wholesale Thermometer 0.68364275
Wholesale Stapler

Wholesale Pin

Wholesale Calculator Wholesale Puzzle 0.373864803
Wholesale Earphone

Level Tape Measure

Bottle Holder Teeth whitening Pen 0.032656741
Wholesale Bangle

Stapless Stapler

Money Clip Lady Beauty Care 0.378775163
Highlighter

Beach Ball

Wholesale Bracelet Reflective Safety Vest 0.265331272
Industrial Thermometers

China Wholesale

Noise Maker Baby Bottle Warmer 0.0853394
Ratchet Tie Down

China Wholesaler

Flashing LED Cups Digital Camera 0.194809315
Wholesale Candle

Wholesale Clothing

Wholesale Golf Products Stuffed Animals 0.316866655
Wholesale Hardware Tools

Wholesale Towel

Wholesale Umbrella Wholesale Clothing 0.26065243
Wholesale Dartboard

rubber sunglasses

Tube Cooler Cake Towel 0.441547616
Writing Instrument

Manicure Set

Solar Products Water Bottle 0.403122455
Wholesale Camera

Wholesale Compass

Eye Mask Valentine Gifts 0.688018722
Money Clip

Wholesale Scale

Wholesale Cards Wholesale Belt 0.816603989
Money Clip

Stamp

Wholesale Racks Wholesale Compressed Products 0.693412227
Wholesale Scissors

Reflective Safety Vest

Arts Crafts Safety Suppliers 0.672654616
Baby Products Suppliers

China Suppliers

Automotive Products Wholesale Cap 0.036155049